inicio email me! RSS

But what these unobservant birds

Poodlerat’s book blog

« The Doom of the Haunted OperaHomeOnce Upon a Time II »

Widdershins

41. Widdershins by Charles de Lint (Urban Fantasy) 560 p.

WiddershinsI’d heard enough good things about Charles de Lint that when I got the chance to buy Widdershins, with its very attractive cover, at half off the remaindered price, I jumped at the chance. I didn’t know much about this book before I read it today, except that it was urban fantasy and part of a loosely-connected series of novels set in the imaginary North American city of Newford. I didn’t know how much I was going to love this book.

Actually, even after I started it, I wasn’t sure I was going to like it at all. The beginning, where a young Celtic fiddler named Lizzie is stranded by car trouble and has her first encounter with the magical world, caught my interest in a limited way. I liked Lizzie, and I wouldn’t have minded seeing a good bit more of her, but the point of view shifted in the next chapter, to a character I wasn’t nearly so interested in (although luckily Lizzie returned throughout the book.)

I’m not a fan of perspective shifts; they only work for me when I’m equally interested in all of the characters, and when the author resolves suspenseful episodes before skipping to another point of view. Charles de Lint doesn’t do that, unfortunately, and it continued to be something of a problem for me throughout the book—although less so as I got to know and be interested in more of his characters.

As Charles de Lint mentions in his author’s note, Widdershins was written partly because of requests from his fans that he write more about a particular character, Jilly, and show her getting together with her friend Geordie, since everyone but the two of them can see that they’re made for each other. I’m very grateful that de Lint didn’t limit the scope of his book to Jilly and Georgie, because I found them by far the least interesting characters in the book—especially when they were together! Maybe it’s because this book was written with established fans in mind, but there was a lot more telling than showing when it came to their personalities; I still don’t feel like I know much about the two of them beyond the things said by other characters in the book.

So I was reading along, mildly interested, but not enough to carry me through a 560-page book. The urban fantasy element wasn’t much different from other things I’d read, the plot wasn’t really going anywhere yet, and the characters weren’t wonderful enough to carry the story on their own. Then I got to page 111, and I started to sit up and take notice.

He was a curious little man, born a treekin—a kind of fairy about the height of a man’s knee, made of twigs and mulch and leaves and moss, all held together in the shape of a human body with a weaving of braided grasses and vines. Treekin needed to replenish their body parts from time to time—when a twig got old and chipped, or when a grass braid snapped and the press of leaves and moss that gave shape to limbs began to fall away. The materials they needed for repair were easy to find, even in a city, for there were always gardens and parks to plunder amongst the tall towers of concrete and steel.

But in the past few decades, many of the treekin began to utilize bits and pieces of electronics and computer parts for their repairs, metamorphosing over time into creatures made as much of wiring and circuitry as they were of organic material. Eventually, some, like Edgan, became creatures entirely made of synthetic castoffs; each techno treekin—as they came to be called—as individual as the materials they were able to scrounge. In Edgan’s case, he had a torso built up around a computer motherboard; his limbs and head were a complicated tangle of wiring and less identifiable objects, though his nose was certainly a spark plug and his eyes a pair of camera lenses.

He was in Computer World tonight because he’d recently seen another of the techno treekin sporting an iPod in the twisting snarl of wires that held her torso together, and he simply had to have one himself. He already had a PDA wired into his motherboard body—as well as a digital camera and a pair of cell phones—but its memory capacity couldn’t match the sixty gigabytes of the iPod. The iPod would be perfect for storing the data he pilfered from the Internet, but he also liked the shiny whiteness of its case for how it matched his spark plug nose.

I don’t know why, but that passage really appealed to me, and from that point on, I was fully engaged in the story Charles de Lint’s characters were telling me. In the end, it’s an intriguing one, about a potential war between the fairies, who came over from Europe with the first North American immigrants, and the Cousins, or First People, who were there before them. It’s also a story about hurt, malice, abuse, and vengeance, and how those things can keep hurting even after the fact. Ultimately, it’s about love and understanding, and about finding common ground. The message was a little heavy-handed, but the plot had a strong enough hold on me that I didn’t much mind.

There were a few other things I was going to mention that could have been better, but on the whole I loved the book so much I don’t want to add too many complaints to my review. Even characters I wasn’t very fond of at first tended to grow on me, and the majority are people I’d like to read more about. That’s why I’m going to end this on a positive note, with another quote (a short one this time!) Here’s an exchange between the crow girls that for no good reason had me in stiches:

“Don’t be rude,” she tells Zia.
“They’re not bribes?”
“Why would out veryvery good friends Geordie and Jilly ever need to bribe us?”
Zia shrugs. “So that we’ll behave?”
“Don’t mind her,” Maida says to me. “She was brought up in a tree by an old magpie.”

Pages read: 11,424

Tags: , , , , , , ,

11 Comments »

Rhinoa wrote, on March 22nd, 2008 at 7:25 pm:

I am trying not to read too much of your review as I just finished the book before it, The Onion Girl and don’t want to spoil the next part of the story. I read enough to see you mostly liked it which is the main thing! I fell in love with his books last year and hope to read them all at some point.

Poodlerat wrote, on March 22nd, 2008 at 9:57 pm:

Although there were a lot of things I thought could have been better, and several things that continued to annoy me throughout the book, I still loved it. The story just swept me away! I’ll definitely be gobbling up all his other books as I come across them.

Jeff S. wrote, on March 23rd, 2008 at 12:30 pm:

Thanks for the review. I picked up this book last year but haven’t had a chance to read it yet. I’ve heard so many good reviews from bloggers about Charles DeLint that I had to pick up some of his books and I loved the cover on Windershins as well.

Poodlerat wrote, on March 23rd, 2008 at 3:17 pm:

You should read it—it’s really good, and it moved quickly. I finished the whole thing in one day.

Eva wrote, on March 27th, 2008 at 3:03 am:

This was my first de Lint, and I really lovd it too! But the second one I read of this, The Little Country, is a stand alone and I loved it even more. In case you’re looking for suggestions. :) For the Once Upon a Time, I’m reading the first of the Newford series, which should be interesting.

Poodlerat wrote, on March 27th, 2008 at 3:06 am:

Oh, I always love suggestions. Although in this case, it’ll probably just come down to which books in the series I happen upon first!

Carl V. wrote, on March 27th, 2008 at 11:23 am:

I absolutely loved the book when I read it last year. Like you, it was my first de Lint book. I don’t have the same complaints you did, in fact I feel just the opposite on those issues but that is what makes us all unique. The fact that we both ended up loving the experience is a testament to the skill of the author. I would love to read Onion Girl and no doubt will some day, but the reason I didn’t want to go read it before Widdershins is that I am a hopeless romantic and loved the idea of knowing this would be the story that would potentially bring these two characters together. I am a big fan of Celtic/Irish music and I don’t know if it was that or what but I really loved Jilly and Geordie, but most especially Jilly. In fact in a recent meme about what characters you would like to meet and hang out with Jilly was one I wanted to put on that list. Charles de Lint writes alot about abuse in his books…at least that is my laymen’s view from the few books of his I have read. As a worker in the mental health field I find his treatment of this to be quite intriguing. I think he demonstrates a real awareness for the need to heal the scars of abuse and retake control of one’s life. I’m so glad you enjoyed it and hope that you read more de Lint in the future. I certainly think he is a pioneer in this mythopoeic subgenre of fantasy and I personally cannot wait to get into more of his work.

Great review by the way!

Poodlerat wrote, on March 27th, 2008 at 11:35 am:

Thank you! Coming from someone whose reviews I enjoy so much, that means a lot. Actually, your review of the book was one of the ones that brought it to my attention, so thank you for that, as well.

I have a feeling that I may like both Jilly and Geordie better in previous books. I kind of touched on it in the review, but I felt like both of them were presented a little differently from the other characters, with less exploration of who they were. This makes sense, since a lot of readers would already have got to know them in other books. I liked Jilly more than Geordie, probably because we got to see her working through her past and dealing with her feelings about it. I think the disconnect for me was being told about how happy and wild and energetically enthusiastic she used to be, but never getting to see more than a glimpse of it in the book. I don’t feel like I’ve met the “real” Jilly yet, but I look forward to the experience!

(I’m also a fan of Celtic music, so that part of the book was really fun—including seeing Grey come around to appreciating the genre!)

/framed wrote, on April 6th, 2008 at 12:36 pm:

I have this book sitting on the shelf so I just skimmed your review. I’m glad to know that you ended up liking it. It sounds like a wonderful book but I’m a little intimidated by the size of it.

Quixotic wrote, on June 20th, 2008 at 3:45 pm:

Glad you loved it!  The more I read by de Lint, the more I love his writing.

I just finished Widdershins recently and blogged about it.  I do think that coming to The Onion Girl and/or Widdershins before reading some of the earlier stories involving Jilly probably lessens the impact of some of the characters.  However, as you and Carl have demonstrated, you can still love the books! 

Dreams Underfoot would be a great one to read (if you haven’t got to it already - I know I am commenting here a bit late!).  It is one of the collections of Newford short stories and there are some truly beautiful stories in there.

Poodlerat wrote, on June 21st, 2008 at 10:29 am:

Yeah, I had a feeling that might be the case—I got the sense that there was a lot of backstory that I didn’t see, and that it took away a bit of the enjoyment from the book. And that’s as it should be—in a long-running series, it’s always a bad sign if you can pick up a late book in the sequence and you immediately know everything from the earlier books!

Thanks for the recommendation—with a prolific author like de Lint, it can be hard to know where to start! I’ve picked up copies of Spirits in the Wires and The Little Country, but I haven’t had time to read them yet.

Your comment